A fresh fish gives you a few signs you can check with your own eyes and nose. They are quality cues, not proof that a fish is safe to eat, and they differ between a whole fish, a fillet and fish sold frozen. This guide follows the seafood buying advice published by the US Food and Drug Administration and the label guidance from the Singapore Food Agency.
Whole fish
On a whole fresh fish with its head on, these are the signs to look for:
- A fresh, mild smell that is not fishy, sour or like ammonia
- Clear, shiny eyes
- Firm flesh that springs back when pressed
- Red gills with no odour
These signs only apply while the head and gills are still on the fish. Once a whole fish has been scaled, gutted or cut for you, some of them can no longer be seen.
Fillets, slices and steaks
A cut has no eyes or gills to check, so the signs are different. Look for firm flesh that springs back when pressed, with no discolouration, darkening or drying around the edges. The smell should still be fresh and mild. If you are choosing between formats, read whole fish or fillet: how to choose and order.
Fish sold frozen
With frozen fish, check the pack rather than the fish. The FDA advises against packs that are open, torn or crushed at the edges, and packs with frost or ice crystals inside, which can mean the fish was stored for a long time or thawed and refrozen. Frozen fish should feel hard, not bendable.
Labels, dates and storage
Appearance cannot tell you everything. The Singapore Food Agency advises reading the label before you buy packed food, including the date mark and any storage instructions. When your order arrives, check the storage label on each pack and store it the way the label says.
When you order online
You cannot smell or touch a fish through a screen, so check what the listing tells you instead: which cut or pack is listed, the weight, and whether that weight is before cleaning. If anything is unclear, ask before you order.